SYRE research · measured November 9, 2026
Which Utah trades businesses do Google's AI and Perplexity recommend, and how consistently?
Very few of them, and not the same ones. On November 9, 2026 we asked Google's AI Mode and Perplexity who to hire for 20 trade-and-city pairs in Salt Lake, Utah, Wasatch and Summit counties, three times each: 360 answers. Of the 2,116 businesses we have on file for those trades and cities, 120 (5.7%) were named even once. Of the 541 businesses the two engines named, 71 (13%) were named by both.
The 20 pairs
Each row is one trade in one city, picked as the pairs with the most businesses on file in each county: 9 in Salt Lake, 7 in Utah, 2 in Wasatch and 2 in Summit. “On file” is our own list of Utah trade businesses, built from public records, counted by mailing address. “Named” means the business came up in at least one of that pair's 18 answers (3 questions, 2 engines, 3 passes).
| Trade | City | County | On file | On file and named | Never named | Businesses the engines named | Named in all 3 passes |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Remodeling | Salt Lake City | Salt Lake | 237 | 7 | 97% | 35 | 15 |
| Landscaping | Salt Lake City | Salt Lake | 234 | 7 | 97% | 35 | 19 |
| Plumbing and HVAC | Salt Lake City | Salt Lake | 223 | 10 | 96% | 24 | 10 |
| House cleaning | Salt Lake City | Salt Lake | 205 | 4 | 98% | 25 | 12 |
| Electrical | Salt Lake City | Salt Lake | 156 | 5 | 97% | 21 | 11 |
| Roofing | Salt Lake City | Salt Lake | 85 | 8 | 91% | 25 | 11 |
| Remodeling | Sandy | Salt Lake | 104 | 5 | 95% | 27 | 15 |
| Landscaping | West Jordan | Salt Lake | 103 | 6 | 94% | 31 | 16 |
| Plumbing and HVAC | West Jordan | Salt Lake | 88 | 9 | 90% | 22 | 13 |
| Landscaping | Orem | Utah | 79 | 3 | 96% | 33 | 16 |
| Remodeling | Orem | Utah | 70 | 5 | 93% | 32 | 18 |
| Landscaping | Lehi | Utah | 69 | 5 | 93% | 33 | 20 |
| Plumbing and HVAC | Orem | Utah | 64 | 6 | 91% | 20 | 13 |
| Landscaping | Provo | Utah | 62 | 3 | 95% | 25 | 15 |
| Electrical | Lehi | Utah | 60 | 5 | 92% | 22 | 13 |
| House cleaning | Orem | Utah | 57 | 2 | 96% | 23 | 13 |
| Landscaping | Heber City | Wasatch | 54 | 11 | 80% | 27 | 16 |
| Home building | Heber City | Wasatch | 51 | 5 | 90% | 29 | 18 |
| Home building | Park City | Summit | 66 | 11 | 83% | 28 | 14 |
| Landscaping | Park City | Summit | 49 | 3 | 94% | 24 | 10 |
| All 20 pairs | 2,116 | 120 | 94% | 541 | 288 |
In every pair the engines named between 20 and 35 businesses in all, and between 2 and 11 of those were on file for that city. The rest were based somewhere else or missing from our list: of the 541 businesses named, 295 (55%) are on file somewhere in the four counties. That says something about our list as well as about the engines.
Matching a name in an answer to a name on file is not exact, so we also counted it the cautious way. Treat a business as possibly named if the first distinctive word of its name shows up anywhere in its pair's 18 answers, or if its website was linked, and 1,749 of the 2,116 (83%) were still never named.
Ask twice, get a different list (on Google)
Perplexity mostly repeats itself. Of the names it gave to a given question, 69% came back in all 3 passes and 16% showed up only once.
Google's AI Mode reshuffles. Of the names it gave to a given question, 24% came back all 3 times and 48% showed up only once.
Pull back to the whole pair, all three questions and both engines, and it steadies: 288 of the 541 businesses (53%) were named in every pass by one question or another. A business that gets named at all tends to come back. On Google it may just not come back for the question your customer typed.
The two engines barely agree
Of the 541 businesses named, 249 came only from Google, 221 only from Perplexity, and 71 (13%) from both. Put the same question to both engines in the same pass and the two answers shared at least one business in 89 of 180 cases (49%). In 19 of the 20 pairs there was at least one business both engines named; in one pair, none.
Both engines named a handful of businesses per answer: 4.6 on average for Google, 4.9 for Perplexity. Google named nobody in 3 of its 180 answers. Perplexity named someone in all 180.
Where the answers come from
The two engines read different places, which fits them naming different businesses.
Google's AI Mode leaned on Google's own business listings. 177 of its 180 answers (98%) linked to Google Maps or a Google business page. After that it linked Angi's request pages in 19% of answers, Thumbtack in 18%, online booking pages hosted by Housecall Pro in 12% and by ServiceTitan in 7%, and Yelp in 6%.
Perplexity leaned on directories. It linked the Better Business Bureau in 116 of its 180 answers (64%), Houzz in 40%, Thumbtack in 26%, Yahoo Local in 17% and Expertise.com in 13%. It linked Google's listings in only 3.
This shows which pages the answers linked to. It does not show that a listing on any of them is why a business got named, and we are not claiming it is.
What an owner in these 20 pairs can check this week
Ask the three questions below for your trade and your city, on both engines, logged out, and ask each one more than once. On Google one try is not enough: nearly half of its per-question names (48%) appeared only once in 3 tries.
Open your Google Business Profile and read it as a customer would. It is what Google's answers linked to in 98% of them, so if it is thin or out of date, that is the page the engine was reading.
Then look your business up on the Better Business Bureau, Houzz and Thumbtack, the three sites Perplexity linked most (64%, 40% and 26% of its answers). See whether you are listed at all, and whether what is there is still true.
What this does not tell you
It is 20 trade-and-city pairs in 8 cities across Salt Lake, Utah, Wasatch and Summit counties, picked because they hold the most businesses on file. It is not a sample of Utah and does not speak for other trades or towns.
It is 2 engines: Google AI Mode and Perplexity's sonar model. Not ChatGPT, not Copilot, and not the AI Overviews at the top of an ordinary Google search.
It is 3 passes, all asked between 3:56 PM and 4:04 PM Mountain Time on Monday, November 9, 2026. It says nothing about how these answers move over days or weeks.
The questions were asked logged out, through a data provider's servers. Someone signed in, with a search history and a location of their own, may see a different answer. Google was given the city as a location; Perplexity was given none, and the city was in the question.
“Named” was read off each answer by a script, not by a person: Google's business cards and business references, and the bold business names in Perplexity's text. It misses some names and sometimes counts two spellings of one business as two. City is a mailing address, so a shop on file in Sandy that works the whole valley counts only for Sandy.
And it records what the engines said, not why they said it.
How we measured it, so you can rerun it
For each pair we asked three questions in a customer's words. The trade word and the job come from the list below; the city is the pair's city.
best {trade word} in {city} Utahwho should I call for {job} in {city}?{trade word} company near {city} Utah
| Trade | Trade word | Job |
|---|---|---|
| Landscaping | landscaper | a new sprinkler system |
| Plumbing and HVAC | plumber | a water heater |
| Remodeling | remodeling contractor | a kitchen remodel |
| House cleaning | house cleaning | a deep clean |
| Electrical | electrician | a panel upgrade |
| Roofing | roofer | a roof leak |
| Home building | home builder | building a custom home |
Each question went to both engines through DataForSEO's API. Google AI Mode got the question with the location set to the city (for example “Orem,Utah,United States”) and the language set to English. Perplexity's sonar model got the question as the whole prompt. We ran the full set 3 times back to back: 20 pairs, 3 questions, 2 engines, 3 passes, 360 answers, none failed.
We kept every raw answer with every link it cited, and the counts above are computed from those files by a script, not by hand. The 20 pairs are the rows of the first table.
SYRE builds and runs systems for Utah trade businesses, at syre.cc.